Cigar Mystery Box 5, Handpicked 5-Stick Cigar Sampler
Discover the thrill of surprise with our Cigar Mystery Box 5, a curated assortment of five premium cigars sourced from top tobacco regions and respected brands:
Hand-selected variety, each box combines different origins, strengths, and formats, perfect for both beginners and experienced aficionados
Exceptional value
Educational adventure, ideal way to explore diverse blends without committing to full boxes
Great gift or treat, pre-wrapped, surprise packaging makes it an exciting present for cigar lovers
Perfect size, five cigars offer a balanced tasting journey across mild, medium, and bold profiles
Whether you’re sampling new favorites, gifting a unique surprise, or simply embracing variety, this premium mystery box delivers quality, value, and discovery.
Add a thoughtful finishing touch to designs made to be carried for years. For a limited time, enjoy complimentary personalisation on the Britannia Nexus and Sierra Maestra collections.
Use code: CRAFT10 at checkout
Dane A. (verified owner) –
Fantastic buy! Very happy with the cigar selection received
SETH C. (verified owner) –
Great cigar selection! I am definitely considering placing another order.
Jason H. (verified owner) –
Great Mystery box! Would buy it again.
Roberto A. (verified owner) –
This mystery box put this shop on the map for me.
Robert (verified owner) –
The best mystery cigar box I ever bought. Well played!!!
Ash A. (verified owner) –
Great selection and quality
Charles D. (verified owner) –
Worth the money !
Chris (verified owner) –
Returning customer for the second time. The Cigars and packaging, just like the first time was really flawless. From the box they come in to the cigars themselves, I salute you guys. Can’t fault it. I will definitely be returning very soon.
Thank you!
Edgar S. (verified owner) –
Very impressed with the selection and quality of cigars!
Ivan Ivanov (verified owner) –
very happy. thank you
Sabrina A. (verified owner) –
WOW! very impressive selection
Warren (verified owner) –
Excellent value for money. Highly recommended.
Bradley (verified owner) –
What a GEM! Very happy with the selection received.
Dana (verified owner) –
Very happy with the selection received!
Alejandro Falcon (verified owner) –
nice selection
Lee Griffin (verified owner) –
Disapointed with the selection tbh was expecting at least one cuban in the pack and im pretty sure umnum is not at the premium end of cigars so as for the selection a big miss for me no point having a petit panatela in there could have been a corona went fir this as all the reviews were good but wont be ordering again
The Cigar Holder –
Good afternoon Lee,
Thank you for taking the time to leave your feedback. We’re sorry to hear the 5 Cigar Mystery Sampler wasn’t what you were hoping for.
The purpose of our mystery boxes is to offer an element of surprise and variety, giving customers the chance to try different cigars they may not usually select themselves. Because of that, we’re unable to guarantee specific brands or origins including Cuban cigars, unless this is clearly stated in the product description. That said, every cigar included is selected to meet our quality standards and offer strong value at the price point.
If you’re looking for particular brands, vitolas, or Cuban cigars specifically, you’re always welcome to order individual cigars directly from our website so you can choose exactly what suits your taste.
We appreciate your comments about the packaging and we’re glad you enjoyed the Late Hour Churchill. If you’d like any recommendations tailored to your preferences, please feel free to email us and we’ll be happy to help.
Thank you again for your feedback.
Best Wishes,
The Cigar Holder